High Five-Figure Settlement Secured for Cyclist After Complex Injury Claim

Client Background

Our client Michelle* (name changed for confidentiality) lives with Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder (EUPD) and had been out of work for several years prior to her accident. Despite the challenges of her pre-existing condition, cycling her e-bike was an important part of her daily routine.

The Accident

While riding, Michelle was involved in a collision with an e-cargo bike. Although the police chose not to prosecute, we successfully established liability against the other party.

The Injuries

Michelle sustained a fracture to her vertebrae. Normally, this type of injury causes discomfort for 6–8 weeks and requires no surgery. However, when combined with her existing mental health condition, the injury added another serious complication to her life and recovery.

The Challenges

This was never going to be a straightforward case. Typically, we would rely on expert evidence from orthopaedic and psychiatric specialists. In this instance, given Michelle’s complex circumstances, we sought to also instruct a pain expert.

The court, however, refused permission for this additional evidence. Meanwhile, the defendants obtained their own medical evidence in both orthopaedics and psychiatry, creating a head-to-head battle over how Michelle’s injuries and prognosis should be assessed.

Our Approach

Despite the restrictions, we built a robust case by carefully coordinating expert testimony, challenging the defence evidence, and ensuring Michelle’s injuries — both physical and psychological — were properly represented.

The Outcome

After a lengthy and hard-fought dispute, we secured a high five-figure settlement for Michelle. Importantly, the case was resolved with no costs awarded against her despite the ferocious battle brought by the defendants.

Key Takeaway

This case highlights the importance of specialist cycling solicitors who understand how to manage complex injuries involving both physical and psychological elements. Even where liability and medical evidence are strongly contested, it is possible to achieve a brilliant result for the injured cyclist.